| Melanie Aguila | Flagler College | 2004 |
| Desiree McKenzie | Southeastern University | 2005 |
| Phillip Gunter | Florida Christian College | 2006 |
| Gaati Werema | Prairie View A&M | 2006 |
| Trinity Robinson | Prairie View A&M | 2006 |
| Chelsea Pennick | FAMU | 2007 |
| Eric Valentin | University of Wisconsin Green Bay | 2007 |
| Daniel Oliver | UNC at Greensboro | 2007 |
| Tyshawn Patterson | Stetson University | 2009 |
| Keith Clanton | University of Central Florida | 2009 |
| Orlando Parker | Wagner University | 2010 |
| Josh Castellanos | Mount St. Marys | 2010 |
| Tariq Mackey | University of Tampa | 2010 |
| Eric Sorice | Warner University | 2010 |
| Ashleigh Diaz | Clearwater Christian College | 2011 |
| Adonis Burbage | Gardner Webb | 2011 |
| Jordan Montgomery | Kennesaw State University | 2012 |
| Isaac Cohen | Columbia University | 2012 |
| Nuri Muhammad | Eastern Florida State College | 2012 |
| Justice Montgomery | American University | 2013 |
| Hope Pawlowski | Nicholls State University | 2013 |
| Michael Walmer | Concordia University | 2013 |
| Dmitri Thompson | Elon University | 2014 |
| Adonys Henriquez | University of Central Florida | 2014 |
| Jonathan Joseph | Stetson University | 2014 |
| Brandon Miller | Gardner Webb | 2014 |
| Brandon Maxwell | Tennessee Chatanooga |
2014 |
| Michael Tolbert | Western Oklahoma State |
2015 |
Josh Raul |
2015 |